Wrist bands and chest straps
An optical wrist band lights the skin and measures the light that comes back as blood volume changes with every heartbeat, but rapid arm motion can break that reading. A chest strap sits closer to the heart's electrical signal and stays accurate when the wrist does not. This page compares the two, gives a clean resting check, and builds training zones from 220 minus age.
Key figures at a glance
| Measurement route | What it senses | Where it sits | What distorts it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wrist optical band | Blood volume at the skin (PPG) | A finger above the wrist bone | Rapid arm motion, loose contact, cold skin |
| Chest strap | Electrical signal at the torso | Across the chest under the pectorals | Dry electrode contact, strap slip |
| Finger pulse oximeter | Blood volume at the fingertip | Clip on a fingertip | Poor perfusion, nail polish, hand cold |
| Ear optical sensor | Blood volume at the ear site | Clipped at the earlobe | Movement of the head, loose clip |
| Normal resting range | Reference band for a calm body | Measured after 5 minutes of sitting | Recent exertion raises the number |
| Desirable resting range | Range cardiologists preferred in 1993 | Reference band, 50 to 90 bpm | Read against the wrong context |
| Training zone (age 40) | 65% to 85% of HRmax 180 bpm | 117 bpm to 154 bpm | Using 220-minus-age as a hard ceiling |
Wrist optical readings track well at rest and break down during rapid arm motion, while chest straps stay accurate throughout.
Optical wrist sensors use photoplethysmography: an LED lights the skin and a photodiode measures the light returned as blood volume changes with every heartbeat. The reading is a volume proxy, not an electrical signal, so anything that changes blood flow at the skin surface changes the number on the screen.
Chest straps measure the heart's electrical activity directly at the torso. In a Stiftung Warentest bike-ride test the wrist tracker failed to track the ride accurately, and chest straps are recommended for maximum accuracy in that situation.
At rest, with the arm still and the band in contact with skin, the two methods usually agree closely enough for zone training. The gap opens as soon as the arm swings hard, the band loosens, or the skin is cold.
Figures were taken from published heart rate references and from the tests and studies cited beside them. No measurement was performed for this page, and no product was tested here.
Sources
Sources are the heart rate references and tests named in the text above.